A Comparison of Small and Large Business Managers' Attitudes Toward Innovation and the Role of Government in Promoting Technology
House Resolution 820 calls for the establishment of technology partnerships, funded by the federal government, designed specifically to improve small businesses access to technology. However, government-industry partnerships have been criticized for creating a government-assisted organization to compete with do1nestic private sector firms. The critics of such partnerships argue that marker intervention by the government often results in competitive disadvantages for the very firms the partnership was intended to help. This study assessed the attitudes of small business owners and managers toward government directed market interventions such as that proposed in HR 820. The results suggest that there are some important differences between managers at large corporations and small businesses on the effectiveness of market intervention by the government, both in terms of job creation and technology enhancement. Within the subsample of small firms, however, there is sharp disagreement on the value of government programs such as those proposed in H.R. 820.
Busi ness Week. ( 1 994) U.S. small busi nesses see only one dark cloud: Washi ngton.
Septem ber 5, 22.
But ler. R.D. ( 1 994) Enterprise zones and development organ i zations: A rc they the
answer to econom ic problems. Proceedi ngs of the Small Busi ness Consu lt i n g
Conference. S1nall Business Institute Directors' Association, San Antonio. TX.,
Davis. B. & M. Frissy. ( 1 993) Cli n ton pl ans expanded role on tech nology. Wall St reet
DcMott. J.S. ( 1993) The Cl i nton push on tech nology. Nat ion's Busi ness. May, 29-32 Healey,
J. ( 1 993) Stimu l us pl an emphasizes qu ick creati on of johs. Con gressional
Quarterl y. March 6, 50 I.
Hi ggi ns, S. ( 1 993) Congress bill wou ld ensu re startu p f unds. PC Weck. Feb. 1 5, I 1 5
Hudson, R.L. ( 1 993) Publ ic push. Wall Street Journal , June 24, R I I.
Lo Storto, C. ( 1 994) An anal ysis of subcontract i ng relat ionships based on the sub
contrac1or/custo1ncr technology exchange port folio; S
the S1nall Business Consulting Confcrcn..:c. Sinai! Business Institute Directors'
Association, San Antonio, TX., 3- 1 I .
M i lls, M. ( 1 993) House panel approves bil lions in research grants to fi rms. Con
gressional Quarterl y. April 3, 835.
Noman i , A. ( 1993) High tech i ndustry's i nfat uat ion with Cli nton turns to frust ration
over u nkcpt vows, i nacti on. Wall Street Journal. September 2. A 1 4.
Rodgers, T.J. ( 1 993) Subsidies- wi th deathly stri ngs. Forbes. Ju ly 1 9, 206.
Saddler. J. ( 1 993) SBA, Commerce square off on high tech fi nancing. Wa ll Street Jou rnal.
Ju ne 9, B I.
Strong, K.C. ( 1 992) I nnovati on. confonni ty, and idiosyncrasy. Unpu bl ished man uscript.
Uni versi ty of Colorado.